DISCIPLINARY LIABILITY OF PUBLIC SERVANTS - WITH PARTICULAR REFERENCE TO EMPLOYEES OF HIGHER EDUCATION SYSTEM - IN RELATION TO DISCIPLINARY LIABILITY OF CIVIL SERVANTS IN THE REPUBLIC OF CROATIA
The paper presents the legal regulation of disciplinary liability of employees of higher education institutions (public servants) and the regulation of disciplinary liability of civil servants in the Republic of Croatia, regulated by the Law on Civil Servants. At the outset, the legal nature of the public service relation is defined as an employment relation, and the concept of public servant is demarcated from civil servant, i.e. the legal definition of public and civil service within the single concept of public administration.
In terms of disciplinary liability arising from the employment relationship, the legislative framework for initiating and conducting disciplinary proceedings, disciplinary acts for which the worker can be held responsible and disciplinary sanctions are determined, with special reference to the Croatian Labour Law. Both procedures are compared: the disciplinary procedure of public officials and the disciplinary procedure of civil servants, and the legal basis is specified.
In the central part of the paper, we outline the disciplinary procedure for higher education employees in accordance with the provisions of the Law on Higher Education and Scientific Activity, including recent changes in the regulation of the disciplinary procedure in relation to the previous Law on Higher Education and Scientific Activity. The procedures of disciplinary liability, disciplinary acts and disciplinary measures determined by the general laws of four higher education institutions in the Republic of Croatia are compared. The authors conclude that the disciplinary procedure for employees of the higher
education institution is vague and insufficiently regulated, because it is only regulated by the Law on Higher Education and Scientific Activity, which is not enough. The applicable law leaves too much autonomy to individual higher education institutions in the Republic of Croatia, which unnecessarily leads to possible different interpretations and a variety of internal regulations of the disciplinary procedure at different higher education institutions. The authors point to the need for additional (joint) legal regulation of procedures for violations of official duties, which would regulate disciplinary actions, minor and severe violations of official duties, procedures and sanctions at all higher education institutions.
Harmonization of rights of all public servants (in state and public services) is suggested, as it would facilitate legal certainty for public servants. Further, adoption of the uniform disciplinary procedure for all public servants similarly is called for, particularly as it is stipulated by the law for all civil servants in the Republic of Croatia.
Keywords: disciplinary liability, public servants, civil servants, higher education institutions.
Bečić, E. 2020. Legal regulation of the responsibilities of civil servants in Bosnia and Herzegovina, Zbornik radova Pravnog fakulteta Sveučilišta u Mostaru, 28(1), pp. 28-51. https://doi.org/10.47960/2637-2495.200.28.28
Borković, I. 2002. Administrative law. VII. amended ed. Zagreb: Narodne novine.
Juras, D. 2013. Judicial protection of the rights of civil servants in disciplinary proceedings. Hrvatska i komparativna javna uprava : časopis za teoriju i praksu javne uprave, 13(2), pp. 541-568.
Potočnjak, Ž. 2013. Labour Relations of Civil Servants. Zagreb: Faculty of Law, University of Zagreb.
Ravnić, A. 2004. Fundamentals of labour law – domestic, comparative and international. Zagreb: Faculty of Law, University of Zagreb.
Šimac, N. 2012. European administrative space and European principles of public administration. Zbornik radova Pravnog fakulteta u Splitu, 49(2), pp. 351-368.
Legal sources
Act on Higher Education and Scientific Activity, Official Gazette nos. 119/2022.
Law on scientific activity and higher education, Narodne novine nos. 123/03, 198/03, 105/04, 174/04, 2/07, 46/07, 45/09, 63/ 11, 94/13, 139/13, 101/14, 60/15 and 131/17.
Code of Conduct for Public Servants, Official Gazette of Republic of Slovenia, nos. 8/01.
Law on Civil Servants, Official Gazette nos. 92/2005, 140/2005, 142/2006, 77/2007, 107/2007, 27/2008, 34/2011, 49/2011, 150/2011, 34/2012, 38/2013, 37/2013, 1/2015, 138/2015, 102/2015, 61/2017, 70/2019, 98/2019, 141/2022.
Law on Civil Servants, Official Gazette of the Republic of Srpska nos. 118/08, 117/11, 37/12. and 57/16.
Law on Civil Service in the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina, Official Gazette of the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina nos. 29/2003-, 23/2004-, 39/2004-, 54/2004-, 67/2005-, 8/2006-, 77 /2006- decision US, 34/2010- decision US, 45/2010 – other law, 4/2012-, 99/2015- and 9/2017- decision of the Constitutional Court.
The Law on Civil Service in the Public Administration Bodies of the Brčko District of Bosnia and Herzegovina, Official Gazette of the Brčko District of Bosnia and Herzegovina nos. 17/2022 – revised text.
Law on Civil Servants, Official Gazette of the Republic of Slovenia nos. 63/07 – official revised text, 65/08, 69/08 – ZTFI-A, 69/08 – Zavar-E, 40/12 – ZUJF, 158/20 – ZIntPK -C, 203/20
ZIUPOPDVE, 202/21 – sec. US in 3/22 – ZDeb.
Law on Salaries in Public Services, Official Gazette nos. 27/01, 39/09.
Law on the State Administration System, Official Gazette nos. 66/19.
Law on Labour Relations, Official Gazette of the Republic of Slovenia nos. 21/13, 78/13 – app., 47/15 – ZZSDT, 33/16 – PZ-F, 52/16, 15/17 – odl. US, 22/19 – ZPosS, 81/19, 203/20 – ZIUPOPDVE, 119/21 – ZČmIS-A, 202/21 – dept. US, 15/22 and 54/22 – ZUPŠ-1.
Regulation on the classification of jobs in the civil service, Official Gazette nos. 77/07 and 81/08.
Regulation on job titles and job complexity coefficients in public services, Official Gazette nos. 25/2013, 72/2013, 151/2013, 9/2014, 40/2014, 51/2014, 77/2014, 83/2014, 87/2014, 120/2014, 147/2014, 151/2014, 11/2015, 32/2015, 38/2015, 60/2015, 83/2015, 112/2015, 122/2015, 10/2017, 39/2017, 40/2017, 74/2017, 122/2017, 9/2018, 57/2018, 59/2019, 79/2019, 119/2019, 50/2020, 128/2020, 141/2020, 17/2021, 26/2021, 78/2021, 138/2021, 9/2022, 31/2022, 72/2022, 82/2022.
Regulation on the rules of disciplinary procedure for disciplinary liability of civil servants in the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina, Official Gazette of the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina nos. 72/04, 75/09, 17/21 and 55/21.
Rulebook on disciplinary and material liability of civil servants, public servants and employees in the administration bodies of the Brčko District of BiH, Official Gazette of the Brčko District nos. 40/06.
Rulebook on disciplinary liability of civil servants in the institutions of Bosnia and Herzegovina, Official Gazette of Bosnia and Herzegovina nos. 20/03 and 94/10.
Internet sources
Regulations on the Work of the Faculty of Philosophy of the University of Zagreb, revised text 2021. Available at: http://maia.ffzg.hr/att/propisi/Pravilnik_o_radu.pdf (3. 6. 2023).
Rulebook on Disciplinary Liability of Teachers and Associates ofJosip Juraj Strossmayer University in Osijek, 2018. Available at: http://www.unios.hr/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/Pravilnik-2018.pdf (3. 6. 2023).
Rulebook on Disciplinary Liability of Teachers and Associates of the University of Rijeka. 2018. Available at: http://www.riteh.uniri.hr/media/filer_public/7e/7a/7e7a8168-a421-4f35-9746-2162c45b3e74/pravilnik_o_stegovnoj_odgovornosti_nastavnika_i_suradnika_sveucilista_u_rijeci.pdf (16. 3. 2023).
Rulebook on Disciplinary Liability of Teachers and Associates of the Faculty of Economics in Split 2018. Available at: https://www.efst.unist.hr/o-fakultetu/fakultet/pravilnici-i-upute (6. 3. 2023).
Statute of the Faculty of Economics, University of Split, revised text 2022. Available at: https://www.efst.unist.hr/o-fakultetu/fakultet/pravilnici-i-upute (6. 3. 2023).
Statute of the Faculty of Philosophy of the University of Zagreb, revised text 2012. Available at: http://dokumenti.ffzg.unizg.hr/propisi/ (6. 3. 2023).
Statute of Josip Juraj Strossmayer University in Osijek, revised text 2022. Available at: https://www.fdmz.hr/images/dokumenti/na-razini-sveucilista/sijecanj_2022_statut-sveucilista-procisceni-tekst-sijecanj-2022.pdf (16. 3. 2023).
Statute of the University of Split, revised text 2021. Available at: https://www.unist.hr/DesktopModules/Bring2mind/DMX/API/Entries/Download?language=hr-HR&EntryId=1874&Command=Core_Download&PortalId=0&TabId=1846 (6. 3. 2023).
Statute of the University of Zagreb, revised text 2017. Available at: http://www.unizg.hr/fileadmin/rektorat/O_Sveucilistu/Dokumenti_javnost/Dokumenti/Strateski_dokumenti/statut/Potpisani_procisceni_tekst_Statuta_Sveucilista_9.10.2017..pdf (6. 3. 2023).
UNESCO, Recommendation concerning the Status of Higher-Education Teaching Personnel, 11 November 1997. Available at: https://en.unesco.org/about-us/legal-affairs/recommendation-concerning-status-higher-education-teaching-personnel (16. 3. 2023).