COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF THE LEGAL STATUS
OF MINISTRIES OF DEFENCE
STAFF
IN SELECTED EUROPEAN COUNTRIES
The objective of the paper is to examine key aspects of human resources management of different categories of personnel in ministries of defence, i.e. civil servants, military officials and other staff categories in Serbia, Croatia and Slovenia. The paper analyses the legal rights and responsibilities of all categories of staff, with a special focus on the recruitment and selection process and remuneration and assesses whether they are in line with international standards. The findings of the analysis demonstrate important exceptions to the principle of merit and public competition rules in the defence sector in all three countries, which poses a serious risk for the application of the merit principle. In all analysed countries there are also separate remuneration legal regimes, which enables the employees in the defence sector to have higher levels of salaries in comparison to their colleagues in the civil service. Although the desire to increase the level of salaries may be understandable in order to increase the motivation of MoD’s staff, this comes with the risk of undermining the unity of the civil service. In order to overcome these issues, it is important to ensure the observance of the merit principle with regard to recruitment and selection of the MoD’s staff based on an open competition. Furthermore, it is recommended that a careful job benchmarking exercise be carried out which would compare the complexity and responsibility of jobs in the civil service and armed forces and align their salary levels in a fair and acceptable manner.
Keywords: legal status, human resources management, Ministry of Defence, Serbia, Croatia, Slovenia.
Cardona, F. 2022. CIDS Position Note on Recruiting for Defence Intelligence Services. Center for Integrity in the Defence Sector. Unpublished manuscript.
Cvijan, V. & Reljanović, M. (eds.). 2007. Pregled zakonodavstva sistema odbrane Republike Srbije. Beograd: Institut za uporedno pravo.
CIDS, 2015. Professionalism and integrity in the Public Service. Guide to Good Governance No. 1/2015.
Đokić, K. & Ignjatijević, M. 2020. Zašto ljudi napuštaju sistem odbrane? Beograd: Beogradski centar za bezbednosnu politiku. Available at: https://bezbednost.org/publikacija/zasto-ljudi-napustaju-sistem-odbrane/ (19. 8. 2022).
Ignjatijević, M. 2020. Zakonske izmene kao reakcija na odliv kadrova iz sistema odbrane, Beograd: Beogradski centar za bezbednosnu politiku. Available at: https://bezbednost.org/publikacija/zakonske-izmene-kao-reakcija-na-odliv-kadrova-iz-sistema-odbrane/ (19. 4. 2023).
Ingraham, P.W. 2006. Building Bridges over Troubled Waters: Merit as a Guide. Public Administration Review, 66(4), pp. 486-495. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6210.2006.00608.x
Lembovska M. 2020. More than (de)politicization: The role of security-intelligence service in (de)capturing the state. Skopje: Euro Think.
Meyer-Sahling, J. H. et al. 2021. Merit Recruitment, Tenure Protections and Public Service Motivation: Evidence from a Conjoint Experiment with 7,300 Public Servants in Latin America, Africa and Eastern Europe. Public Administration, 99(4), pp. 740-757. https://doi.org/10.1111/padm.12708
Meyer-Sahling, J. H. et al. 2019. Merit Recruitment in the Western Balkans: An Evaluation of Change between 2015 and 2019. Danilovgrad: ReSPA Publications.
Meyer-Sahling, J.H. et al. 2015. Improving the Implementation of Merit Recruitment Procedures in the Western Balkans: Analysis and Recommendations. Danilovgrad: ReSPA Publications.
Milošević, M. 2013. Control and Oversight of Intelligence and Security Services. In: Rabrenović, A. (ed.) Legal Mechanisms for Prevention of Corruption in South East Europe with Special Focus on the Defence Sector. Beograd: Institute of Comparative Law.
Kopecky, P. at al. (eds.). 2012. Party Patronage and Party Government in European Democracies, Comparative Politics. Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199599370.001.0001
Kunić, P. 2008. Upravno pravo: posebni dio. Banja Luka: Pravni fakultet u Banja Luci i Fakultet za bezbjednost i zaštitu.
Ongaro E. 2009. Public Management Reform and Modernization: Trajectories of Administrative Change in Italy, France, Greece, Portugal and Spain. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar. https://doi.org/10.4337/9781849802284
Van der Mer, F. et al. 2015. Comparative Civil Service Systems in the 21st Century. 2nd edition. Palgrave: Macmillan. https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137491459
Rabrenović A., Hadžić, M. & Misailović, J. 2022. Specificities of Recruitment and Selection in the Defence Sector – the Case of Montenegro. In: Reljanović, M. (ed.) Regional Law Review. Belgrade: Institute of Comparative Law. https://doi.org/10.56461/iup_rlrc.2022.3.ch5
SIGMA/OECD. 2021. Monitoring Report. The Principles of Public Administration – Serbia. OECD publishing.
SIGMA/OECD. 2017. Methodological framework for the Principles of Public Administration. OECD publishing.
SIGMA/OECD. 2014. Principles of Public Administration. OECD publishing.
Sofat, P. 2016. Human Resource Management in the Armed Forces, Transition of a Soldier to a Second Career. IDSA monograph series no. 54. Institute for Defense Studies and Analysis.
Šegvić, S. 2004. Pravo obrane i unutarnjih poslova Republike Hrvatske. Split: Pravni fakultet grad Split.
Vukašinović Radojičić, Z. 2013. Evropski službenički sistemi. Beograd: Kriminalističko policijska akademija.
Vranješ, N. & Đurić, V. 2018. Državna služba i upravljanje ljudskim resursima u institucijama Bosne i Hercegovine i Republici Srpskoj – eksterna evaluacija i budući izazovi. Pravna riječ (54), pp. 383-406.
Legal sources
Law on Ministries, Official Gazette of the Republic of Serbia nos.128/2020, 116/2022.
Law on Defence, Official Gazette of the Republic of Serbia nos. 116/2007, 88/2009, 88/2009,104/2009, 10/2015, 36/2018.
Civil Service Law, Official Gazette of the Republic of Serbia no. 79/2005, 81/2005, 83/2005, 64/2007, 67/2007, 116/2008, 104/2009, 99/2014, 94/2017, 95/2018, 157/2020 and 142/2022.
Law on the Serbian Armed Forces, Official Gazette of the Republic of Serbia nos. 116/2007, 88/2009, 101/2010, 10/2015, 88/2015, 36/2018, 94/2019 and 74/2021.
Amendments to the Civil Service Law, Official Gazette of the Republic of Serbia no. 157/2020.
Law on Civil Service Salaries, Official Gazette of the Republic of Serbia nos. 62/2006, 63/2006, 115/2006, 101/2007, 99/2010, 108/2013, 99/2014 and 95/2018.
Decree on Job Classification and Criteria for Job Descriptions of Civil Servants, Official Gazette of the Republic of Serbia nos. 79/2005, 81/2005, 83/2005, 64/2007, 67/2007, 116/2008, 104/2009, 99/2014, 94/2017, 16/202018, 2/2019 and 4/2019.
Decree on the classification of formation duties and titles in the Slovenian Army into salary classes, Official Gazette of the Republic of Slovenia nos. 71/08, 78/08, 85/10, 46/17, 86/18 and 6/22.
Law on Defence, Official Gazette of the Republic of Slovenia nos. 103/04 – official consolidated text, no. 95/15 and 139/20.0.
Law on Public Servants of Slovenia, Official Gazette of the Republic of Slovenia nos. 56/02, no. 32/05 and no. 63/07.
Law on the Salary System in the Public Sector, Official Gazette of the Republic of Slovenia nos. 108/09 – updated. version, 13/10, 59/10, 85/10, 107/10, 35/11 – ORZSPJS49a, 27/12
US, 40/12 – ZUJF, 46/13, 25/14 – ZFU, 50/14, 95/14 – ZUPPJS15, 82/15, 23/17 – ZDOdv, 67/17, 84/18 and 204/21.
Decree on Internal organisation of the Ministry of Defence, Official Gazette of the Republic of Croatia nos. 97/20.
Civil Service Law (Zakon o drzavnim sluzbenicima), Official Gazette of the Republic of Croatia nos. 92/05, 140/05, 142/06, 77/07, 107/07, 27/08, 34/11, 49/11, 150/11, 34/12, 49/12, 37/13, 38/13, 1/15, 138/15, 61/17, 70/19 and 98/19.
Decree on Names of Job Posts and Coefficients for Complexity of Work in the Civil Service, Official Gazette of the Republic of Croatia nos. 37/01, 38/01 – ispravak, 71/01, 89/01, 112/01, 7/02 – ispravak, 17/03, 197/03, 21/04, 25/04 – ispravak, 66/05, 131/05, 11/07, 47/07, 109/07, 58/08, 32/09, 140/09, 21/10, 38/10, 77/10, 113/10, 22/11, 142/11, 31/12, 49/12, 60/12, 78/12, 82/12, 100/12, 124/12, 140/12, 16/13, 25/13, 52/13, 96/13, 126/13, 2/14, 94/14, 140/14, 151/14, 76/15, 100/15, 71/18, 73/19 and 63/21.
Law on the Armed Forces, Official Gazette of the Republic of Croatia nos. 73/13, 75/15, 50/16, 30/18 and 125/19.
Law on Defence, Official Gazette of the Republic of Croatia nos. 73/13, 75/15, 27/16, 110/17, 30/18, 70/19.
Other sources
Defence Strategy of the Republic of Serbia, Official Gazette of the Republic of Serbia no. 94/2019.
Information Booklet of the Ministry of Defence of Serbia, updated on the 1st of June, 2023. Serbia: Ministry of Defence of the Republic of Serbia.
Regulation on internal organization, systematization, jobs and titles in public administration bodies and judicial bodies, Official Gazette of the Republic of Slovenia no. 58/03, 81/03, 109/03, 43/04, 58/04 – cor. , 138/04, 35/05, 60/05, 72/05, 112/05, 49/06, 140/06, 9/07, 33/08, 66/08, 88/08, 8/09, 63 /09, 73/09, 11/10, 42/10, 82/10, 17/11, 14/12, 17/12, 23/12, 98/12, 16/13, 18/13, 36/13 , 51/13, 59/13, 14/14, 28/14, 43/14, 76/14, 91/14, 36/15, 57/15, 4/16, 44/16, 58/16, 84 /16, 8/17, 40/17, 41/17, 11/19, 25/19, 54/19, 67/19, 89/20, 104/20, 118/20, 168/20, 31/21 , 54/21, 203/21, 29/22, 80/22, 103/22 and 125/22.
Decision on Basic Salary Supplements in the Ministry of Defence and the Armed Forces of the Republic of Croatia, Official Gazette of the Republic of Croatia no. 92/18 of 17/10/2018.